Skip to main content

Full text of "DTIC ADA368460: Action of the p53 Effector, p2l, on its Targets: Cyclin cdk and PCNA"

See other formats


AD 


AWARD  NUMBER  DAMD17 -97-1-73 14 


TITLE:  Action  of  the  p53  Effector,  p21,  on  its  targets:  Cyclin- 
cdk  and  PCNA 


PRINCIPAL  INVESTIGATOR:  Anindya  Dutta,  M.D.,Ph.D. 


CONTRACTING  ORGANIZATION:  Brigham  and  Women's  Hospital 
,  Boston,  Massachusetts  02115 


REPORT  DATE:  October  1998 


TYPE  OF  REPORT:  Annual 


PREPARED  FOR:  U.S.  Army  Medical  Research  and  Materiel  Command 
Fort  Detrick,  Maryland  21702-5012 


DISTRIBUTION  STATEMENT:  Approved  for  Public  Release; 

Distribution  Unlimited 


The  views,  opinions  and/or  findings  contained  in  this  report  are 
those  of  the  author (s)  and  should  not  be  construed  as  an  official 
Department  of  the  Army  position,  policy  or  decision  unless  so 
designated  by  other  documentation. 


19990928  392 


DUC  QUALITY  INSPECTED  4 


REPORT  DOCUMENTATION  PAGE 


Form  Approved 
0MB  No,  0704-0188 


Public  reporting  burdm  for  this  collection  of  information  it  estimated  to  average  1  hour  per  response,  including  the  time  for  reviewing  instructions,  searching  existing  data  sources, 
gathering  and  maintaining  the  data  needed,  and  completing  and  reviewing  the  collection  of  information.  Send  comments  regarding  this  burden  estimate  or  any  other  aspect  of  this 
collection  of  information,  including  suggestions  for  reducing  this  burden,  to  Washington  Headquarters  Services,  Directorate  for  Information  Operations  and  Reports,  1215  Jefferson 
Davis  Highway,  Suite  1 204,  Arlington,  VA  22202-4302,  and  to  the  Office  of  Management  end  Budget,  Paperwork  Reduction  Project  (0704-0188),  Washington,  DC  20503. 


AGENCY  USE  ONLY  (Leave  blank) 


2,  REPORT  DATE 

October  1998 


3.  REPORT  TYPE  AND  DATES  COVERED 
Annual  (22  Sep  97  -  21  Sep  98) 


4.  TITLE  AND  SUBTITLE 

Action  of  the  p53  Effector,  p21,  on  It's  Targets:  Cyclin-cdk  and  PCNA 


5.  FUNDING  NUMBERS 
DAMD17-97-1-7314 


6.  AUTHOR(S) 

Anindya  Dutta,  M.D.,Ph.D. 


7.  PERFORMING  ORGANIZATION  NAME(S)  AND  ADDRESS(ES) 
Brigham  and  Women's  Hospital 
Boston,  Massachusetts  02115 


8.  PERFORMING  ORGANIZATION 
REPORT  NUMBER 


9.  SPONSORING  /  MONITORING  AGENCY  NAME(S)  AND  ADDRESS(ES) 
U.S.  Army  Medical  Research  and  Materiel  Command 
Fort  Detrick,  Maryland  21702-5012 


10.  SPONSORING  /  MONITORING 
AGENCY  REPORT  NUMBER 


12a.  DISTRIBUTION  /  AVAILABILITY  STATEMENT 
Approved  for  Public  Release;  Distribution  Unlimited 


12b.  DISTRIBUTION  CODE 


13.  ABSTRACT  (Maximum  200  words! 

CXm  aim  is  to  dissect  the  interactions  of  p21  (a  downstream  effector  of  the  tumor  suppressor  protein 
p53)  Y^th  its  two  target,  cyclin-cdks  and  PCNA.  In  year  1  we  have  estabUshed  conditions  for 
quantitatively  analyzing  the  inhibition  of  cyclin-cdk  by  p21.  This  wiU  enable  us  to  measure  the 
exact  contribution  of  the  interaction  between  the  cyclin-binding  Cy  motif  of  p21  with  a  docking  site 
on  the  cyclin  in  the  inhibition  of  kinase  activity.  The  conditions  obtained  have  already 
demonshated  qualitatively  the  importance  of  the  Cy  motif  in  kinase  inhibition.  Different  methods 
of  site  directed  mutogenesis  are  teing  tried  to  determine  the  optimal  method  by  which  to  generate  a 
hbrary  of  mutants  in  the  Cy  motif  of  p21.  In  year  2  this  library  of  mutants  will  enable  us  to 
quantitatively  deteimine  exactly  what  constitutes  a  functional  Cy  motif.  In  order  to  dissect  the 
mteraction  of  p21  with  PCNA  we  now  have  mutant  forms  of  PCNA  that  fail  to  interact  with  p21  or 
with  the  exonuclease  Fenl  without  disrupting  the  trimeric  structure  of  PCNA.  This  is  the  first  step 
towards  analyzing  how  the  p21-PCNA  interaction  impinges  on  DNA  replication  and  repair  in 
cancer  cells. 


14.  SUBJECT  TERMS 
Breast  Cancer  PCNA 
P21  Cell  Cycle 

p53 


17.  SECURITY  CLASSIFICATION 
OF  REPORT 

Unclassified 


1 8.  SECURITY  CLASSIFICATION 
OF  THIS  PAGE 

Unclassified 


15.  NUMBER  OF  PAGES 

16 _ 

16.  PRICE  CODE 


19.  SECURITY  CLASSIFICATION  20.  LIMITATION  OF  ABSTRACT 
OF  ABSTRACT 


Undassified 


Unlimited 


NSN  7540-01-280-5500 


Standard  Form  298  (Rev.  2-89) 

Prescribed  by  ANSI  Std.  Z39-18  298-102 


USAPPC  VI  .00 


FOBEWORD 


interpretations,  conclusions  and  recosmendations  are 
those  of  the  author  and  are  not  necessarily  endorsed  by  the  U.S. 
Amy. 

—  Where  cop3^ighted  material  is  <zuoted,  permission  has  been 
obtained  to  use  such  material. 

—  ^ere  material  from  documents  designated  for  limited 

distribution  is  quoted,  permission  has  been  obtained  to  use  the 
material . 


— _  Citations  of  commercial  organizations  and  trade  names  in 
this  report  do  not  constitute  an  official  Department  of  Army 
endorsement  or  approval  of  the  products  or  services  of  these 
organizations . 


-  conducting  research  using  animals,  the  investigator (s) 

adhered  to  the  "Guide  for  the  Care  and  Use  of  Laboratory 
Animals, "  prepared  by  the  Committee  on  Care  and  use  of  Laboratory 
Animals  of  the  Institute  of  Laboratory  Resources,  national 
Research  Council  (NIH  Pxiblication  No.  86-23,  Revised  1985) . 

Jlic.  For  the  protection  of  human  subjects,  the  investigator (s) 
adhered  to  policies  of  applicable  Federal  Law  45  CFR  46. 

^  coi^ucting  research  utilizing  recombinant  DNA  technology, 
investigator (s)  adhered  to  current  guidelines  promulgated  by 
the  National  Institutes  of  Health. 

conduct  of  research  utilizing  recombinant  DNA,  the 
investigator (s)  adhered  to  the  NIH  Guidelines  for  Research 
Involving  Recombinant  DNA  Molecules. 


In  the  conduct 
the  investigator (s) 
Microbiological  and 


of  research  involving  hazardous  organisms, 
adhered  to  the  CDC-NIH  Guide  for  Biosafety 
Biomedical  Laboratories . 


in 


/i/iH  hr 


PI  -  signature 


Date 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS  PAGE 

INTRODUCTION  2 

BODY  3 

METHODS  4 

RESULTS  AND  DISCUSSION  5 

CONCLUSION  7 

FIGURE  LEGENDS  7 

FIGURES  8 

REFERENCES  13 


1 


INTRODUCTION: 


Importance  of  p53  function  in  breast  cancer:  As  discussed  extensively  in  the 
original  grant  proposal,  the  p53  protein  is  an  important  tumor  suppressor  which  is 
inactivated  by  mutation  in  up  to  50%  of  breast  cancers.  In  multiple  studies,  mutation  of  the 
p53  gene  in  a  breast  cancer  is  associated  with  shorter  disease  free  interval  and  decreased 
overall  survival,  independent  of  the  presence  of  axillary  node  metastases.  In  a  small  group 
of  familial  breast  cancer  patients  (with  Li  Fraumeni  syndrome),  inactivating  germ-line 
mutations  are  seen  in  the  p53  gene,  indicating  the  importance  of  normal  p53  in  preventing 
the  appearance  and  progression  of  breast  cancers. 

p53  and  n21:  Both  the  germinal  and  the  somatic  mutations  of  p53  which  are  seen 
in  cancers  appear  to  be  "loss  of  function"  mutations.  p53  is  believed  to  suppress  cell 
growth  by  the  transcriptional  induction  of  genes  that  negatively  regulate  cell  growth.  One 
such  gene,  discovered  is  the  p21  gene  (1). 

p21  belongs  to  one  class  of  cdk  inhibitors  which  are  related  to  each  other  in  their 
primary  sequence  and  their  substrate  specificity.  These  associate  with  and  inhibit  almost  all 
cyclin-cdk  pairs,  and  the  three  members  of  this  class  are  p21,  p27  and  p57. 

Domain  structure  of  n21 :  Beside  inhibiting  cyclin-cdk  kinases,  the  p21  protein  directly 
interacts  with  and  inhibits  an  essential  DNA  replication  factor,  proliferating  cell  nuclear 
antigen  (PCNA)  (2-4).  The  N  terminal  domain  of  p21  (p21N)  interacts  with  the  cd^ 
protein  and  inhibits  cyclin-cdk  kinase  activity,  while  the  C  terminal  domain  (p21C)  interacts 
with  and  inhibits  PCNA,  the  ring  shaped  sliding  clamp  that  tethers  DNA  polymerases  delta 
and  epsilon  to  the  replicating  strand. 

The  cvclin  bindinn  motif  in  n21:  Further  dissection  of  the  cdk  inhibitory  domain  present  in 
p21N  demonstrated  that  a  cyclin  binding  motif  on  p21  allows  it  to  directly  bind  to  cyclins 
(5).  The  cyclin  binding  sequence,  ACRRLFGPV,  is  highly  conserved  in  the  other  cdk 
inhibitors,  p27  and  p57,  and  is  also  conserved  in  substrates  and  activators  of  cdks.  A 
twelve  amino  acid  peptide  containing  this  motif  is  sufficient  to  interact  with  cyclins. 
Together  with  our  biochemical  data,  the  crystallographic  structure  of  cyclin  A-cdk2 
complexed  with  p27  (6),  suggests  that  the  Cy  motif-  cyclin  interaction  serves  as  a  docking 
interaction  essential  for  the  complete  interaction  between  cdk  inhibitors  and  cyclin-cdk.  In 
this  project  we  shall  determine  how  the  cyclin  binding  site  of  p21  contributes  to  inhibition 
of  cyclin-cdk  kinase,  and  the  implications  of  this  discovery  for  designing  chemicals  that 
mimic  p21  action  by  binding  cyclin  or  cdk2. 

The,  effect  of  p21  on  the  function  of  PCNA.  PCNA  inhibition  by  p21  is  also  important  for 
growth  control  (7, 8).  We  have  recently  shown  that  in  serum-starved  diploid  fibroblasts, 
the  introduction  of  the  PCNA  inhibitory  portion  of  p21  (without  the  cdk  kinase  inhibitor 
domain)  is  also  sufficient  to  inhibit  cell  growth  (8).  Hence,  in  the  second  portion  of  this 
proposal  we  shall  study  the  mechanism  by  which  p21  affects  the  function  of  PCNA. 

p21  disrupts  the  association  of  PCNA  with  the  5’-3’  exonuclease  Fenl.  Prokaryotic  DNA 
replication  polymerases  possess  three  activities:  a  5’-3’  DNA  polymerase,  a  3’-5’ 
exonuclease  (the  proof-reading  activity)  and  a  5’-3’  exonuclease.  None  of  the  DNA 
polymerases  identified  in  human  cells  possess  the  last  activity.  A  5’-3’  exonuclease  is 
however  essential  for  complete  DNA  replication,  and  has  been  purified  by  virtue  of  its 
requirement  in  the  SV40  based  DNA  replication  reaction  (9).  In  the  absence  of  this  special 
exonuclease  the  ribonucleotide-deoxyribonucleotide  bond  at  the  5’  ends  of  Okazaki 
fragments  is  not  removed  and  consequently  the  Okazaki  fragments  are  not  ligated.  This 
exonuclease  has  been  independently  identified  as  a  flap  endonuclease  (Fenl)  required  for 
DNA  recombination  (10, 11)  and  as  a  gene  essential  for  (a)  cell-cycle  progression  and  (b) 


2 


protection  from  radiation  induced  DNA  damage  in  yeast  S.  cerevisiae  (YKL510  or  RAD27 
or  ERCl)  and  S.  pombe  (rad2)  (12-14).  Mutation  of  this  gene  in  S.  cerevisiae  also 
produces  an  instability  of  direct  repeats  much  like  the  instability  seen  in  several  human 

cancers  (15).  , 

We  reported  that  Fenl/Rad2  directly  associates  with  PCNA  and  that  p21  disrupts 
the  association  of  Fenl  with  PCNA  (16).  This  newly  discovered  activity  of  p21  is  likely  to 
be  important  for  the  propagation  of  DNA  mutations  following  DNA  replication,  because 
unlinking  Fenl  from  PCNA  by  p21  may  promote  the  same  type  of  genomic  instability  as 
seen  when  RAD27  is  mutated  in  S.  cerevisiae.  In  this  proposal  we  shall  seek  derivatives  of 
PCNA  which  have  uncoupled  the  PCNA-pol  delta  and  PCNA-Fenl  interactions.  These 
studies  will  in  addition  illuminate  whether  the  complete  action  of  p21  on  the  DNA 
replication  apparatus  requires  that  both  these  interactions  of  PCNA  be  breached.  The 
results  will  determine  whether  uncoupling  of  the  polymerase  from  the  exonuclease  by  p21 
contributes  to  the  genomic  instability  seen  in  several  breast  cancers  and  also  indicate 
whether  the  PCNA-Fenl  complex  could  on  its  own  be  a  suitable  target  for  chemotherapy. 

BODY 

Original  Statement  of  work 

Technical  objective  1.  Analysis  of  the  interaction  between  p21,  cyclin  and  cdk. 

Task  1:  Months  1-12:  Determination  of  the  binding  affinity  of  the  cyclin-binding  site  for  cyclins 
and  of  the  cdk2  binding  site  for  cdk2  and  comparison  with  the  binding  affinity  of  intact  p21 
with  the  cyclin  E-cdk2  holoenzyme. 

Task  2:  Months  12-24:  T.ineweaver-Burke  analysis  of  the  inhibition  of  cvclin  E-cdk2  bv  intact 
p21  and  bv  p21  without  the  cvclin  binding  site. 

Task  2:  Months  24-36:  Olipomicleotide  directed  mutagenesis  of  the  portion  of  p21  in  the 
cyclin  binding  site  to  determine  what  sequence  feature  is  essential  for  binding  to  cvclins. 

Technical  objective  2.  Analysisoftheinteractionbetweenp21,  PCNA  and  Fenl. 

Task  5:  Months  1-12:  Determination  of  which  part  of  PCNA  interacts  with  n21  and  with 
Fenl. 


The  underlined  tasks  are  being  done  now.  We  have  slightly  re-ordered  our  priorities  in 
Objective  1  because  obtaining  the  mutant  forms  of  the  cyclin-binding  motif  (originally  planned 
for  months  24-36)  will  significantly  improve  our  measurements  of  binding  affinity  of  cyclin- 
binding  sites  for  cyclins  and  the  contribution  of  these  sites  to  the  association  of  p21  with 
cyclin-cdks  (Task  1) .  Hence  from  this  objective.  Task  2  is  being  attempted  now  as  Task  1  and 
the  original  Task  1  has  been  moved  back.  This  is  reflected  in  the  revised  Statement  of  Work 
below: 

Technical  objective  1.  Analysis  of  the  interaction  between  p21,  cyclin  and  cdk. 

Task  1:  Months  1-24:  Oligonucleotide  directed  mutagenesis  of  Ae  portion  of  p21  in  the  cyclin 
binding  site  to  determine  what  sequence  feature  is  essential  for  binding  to  cyclins. 

Task  1:  Months  1-24:  Lineweaver-Burke  analysis  of  the  inhibition  of  cyclin  E-cdk2  by  intact 
p21  and  by  p21  without  the  cyclin  binding  site. 


3 


Task  2:  Months  24-36:  Determination  of  the  binding  affinity  of  the  cyclin-binding  site  for 
cyclins  and  of  the  cdk2  binding  site  for  cdk2  and  comparison  with  the  binding  affinity  of  intact 
p21  with  the  cyclin  E-cdk2  holoenzyme. 

Task  3:  Months  24-48:  Creation  and  testing  of  mutations  of  p21  with  different  affinities  for 
cyclins  D1  and  E. 

Task  4:  Months  24-48:  Creation  and  testing  of  versions  of  p21  with  variation  of  the  distance 
between  the  cyclin-binding  and  the  cdk2  binding  sites  (in  cis). 

Technical  objective  2.  Analysis  of  the  interaction  between  p21,  PCNA  and  Fen  1. 

Task  5:  Months  1-12:  Determination  of  which  part  of  PCNA  interacts  with  p21  and  with 
Fenl. 

Task  6:  Months  12-24:  Creation  of  p21  derivatives  and  determination  of  their  IC90  on  the 
processivity  of  PCNA-polymerase  delta. 

Task  7:  Months  24-36:  Creation  and  testing  of  PCNA  mutants  that  have  lost  the  interaction 
with  Fenl  but  can  still  stimulate  polymerase  delta 

Task  8:  Months  36-48:  Testing  effect  of  adding  Fenl  to  replication  reactions  or  over¬ 
expressing  Fenl  in  MCF-7  cells  in  culture. 

METHODS. 

Inhibition  of  cyclin  E-cdk2  by  intact  p21  and  by  p21  without  the  cyclin- 
binding  site. 

The  substrate  used  was  GST-CDC25A  produced  in  bacteria  and  purified  on  glutathione 
agarose  beads..  The  enzyme  (cyclin  E-cdk2)  was  prepared  by  co-inf(^ting  SF9  insect  celk 
with  two  baculoviruses  expressing  GST-cyclin  E  and  cdk2.  Active  kinase  complex  is  purified 
on  glutathione  agarose  beads.  Both  substrate  and  enzyme  were  eluted  with  glutathione. 

To  determine  initial  velocity  conditions  for  the  kinase  reaction,  4  ng  GST-cyclin  E/cdk2 
was  incubated  with  2  or  0.2  |Xg  of  GST-CDC25A  in  25  |xl  reaction  buffer  containing  50  mM 

Tris-HCl  pH  7.4, 10  mM  MgC12, 1  mM  DTT,  50  pM  ATP  containing  5  pCi  ganama  32P-ATP 
(sp.  activity  3200  cpm/pmol).  Reaction  was  allowed  to  proceed  for  indicated  periods  of  time  at 
37  deg.  c  and  stopped  by  boiling  in  Laemmli  sample  buffer.  Products  were  separated  by  gel 
electrophoresis,  GST-CDC25A  visualized  by  autoradiography,  and  radioactivity  incorporated 
into  the  band  counted  by  liquid  scintillation  counting. 

To  determine  conditions  for  inhibition  by  p21,  bacterially  produced  GST-p21  was 
purified  by  glutathione  agarose  affinity  chromatography  and  titrated  into  the  reaction  (from  0.1 

to  1000  ng).  In  addition  p21  derivatives  with  deletions  in  the  Cy  motif  (A17-24)  and  K  motif 

(A53-58)  and  12  mer  peptides  containing  the  Cy  motif  (PS  100)  and  with  a  mutation  in  the  Cy 
motif  (PS  101)  were  tested  for  their  inhibition. 

Mutagenesis  of  the  Cy  motif  of  p21. 

The  following  strategies  were  tried  in  parallel. 


4 


1)  A  PCR-based  strategy.  Diverging  oligonucleotides  were  made  that  annealed  to  the  Cy  motif 
region  of  p21  but  incorporated  specific  mutations.  PCR  with  these  oligonucleotides  and  others 
that  anneal  to  the  ends  of  p21N  cDNA  generated  fragments  of  90  and  200  nucleotides  which 
were  then  annealed  to  each  other  (through  their  overlap  at  the  Cy  motif  region  and  re-PCR-ed 
with  the  end-specific  oligonucleotides).  The  goal  was  to  produce  a  270  base-pair  long 
fragment  that  would  contain  the  mutant  Cy  motif  which  would  then  be  cloned  into  the  pGEX 
vector  to  produce  GST-p21N  with  point-mutation  in  the  Cy  motif. 

2)  A  cassette  based  strategy.  PCR-based  mutagenesis  of  GEX-p21N  introduced  a  Hindlll  site 
at  the  N  terminal  end  of  the  Cy  motif  (a  silent  mutation).  Together  with  a  naturally  occurring 
BlpI  site  on  the  C  terminal  side  of  the  Cy  motif,  this  allowed  us  to  excise  the  wild-type  Cy 
motif.  Synthetic  oligonucleotides  were  annealed  so  that  a  mutant  Cy  motif  was  encoded  by  the 
cassette  and  cloned  between  the  Hindlll-BlpI  sites  of  GEX-p21N. 

3)  The  Kunkel  method  of  mutagenesis.  p21N  was  cloned  into  a  vector  (Blue-Script)  that  can 
produce  single-stranded  DNA.  deoxy-Uridine  containing  single-stranded  DNA  template  was 
prepared  in  CJ236  (dut,  ung)  bacteria.  Annealing  of  mutant  oligonucleotides  (containing  a 
point-mutation  in  the  Cy  motif)  to  this  template  followed  by  E.  coli  Klenow  polymerase 
directed  in  vitro  synthesis  and  transformation  into  wild-type  (dut+„  ung+)  bacteria  is  expected 
to  select  against  the  deoxy-Uridine  containing  single-stranded  DNA  template  so  that  most  of  the 
colonies  obtained  will  encode  the  mutant  Cy  motif. 

Determination  of  the  part  of  PCNA  that  interacts  with  p21  and  Fenl. 

A  report  appeared  in  the  Literature  (17)  that  indicated  residues  QI^I  in  the  inter-domain 
connecting  loop  of  PCNA  was  important  for  die  association  of  PCNA  with  p21  and 
dispensable  for  forming  a  PCNA  trimer.  Plasmids  encoding  the  mutant  forms  of  PCNA 
described  in  that  report  were  obtained  from  the  authors.  Bacterially  produced  GST-p21  and  to 
GST-FenlC  (containing  the  C  terminal  portion  of  Fenl  which  interacts  with  PCNA)  were 
bound  to  glutathione  agarose  beads  and  their  association  with  PCNA  assayed  as  described  by 
us  (16).  The  wild  type  and  mutant  forms  of  PCNA  were  produced  in  two  ways:  (a)  by  in 
vitro-transcription  translation  in  rabbit  reticulocyte  lysates  and  (ii)  by  expressing  in  E.  coli. 
PCNA  produced  by  in  vitro  transcription-translation  was  labeled  with  35S  methionine  and 
visualized  by  fluorography,  while  the  bacterially  produced  PCNA  was  visualized  by 
immunoblotting  with  commercial  anti-PCNA  antibody. 

RESULTS  AND  DISCUSSION 

Inhibition  of  cyclin  E-cdk2  by  intact  p21  and  by  p21  without  the  cyclin- 
binding  site. 

Fig.  1  indicates  that  with  2  |ig  of  GST-CDC25A  the  kinase  activity  is  linear  beyond 
10  minutes.  Thus  for  the  inhibition  assays  the  kinase  reaction  was  stopped  at  10  minutes. 

Fig.  2A  shows  that  compared  to  wild  type  p21,  p21A17-24  (deletion  in  one  of  the 
cyclin  binding  motif,  Cyl)  is  almost  50  fold  weaker  in  its  inhibitory  potency,  while 
p21A53-58  (deletion  in  the  cdk  binding  K  motif)  is  about  8  fold  weaker.  This  surprising 
result  indicates  that  for  certain  substrates  the  Cyl  motif  of  p21  is  even  more  important  than 
the  K  or  Cy2  motifs  for  inhibition  of  cyclin  E-cdk2.  In  the  future,  we  wiU  examine 
whether  the  same  holds  for  cyclin  A-cdk2  (which  might  prefer  the  Cy2  motif  near  the  C 
terminus  of  p21  over  the  Cyl  motif  in  the  N  terminal  half).  We  will  also  examine  the 
inhibitory  reaction  with  a  mutant  substrate  lacking  a  Cy  motif,  GST-CDC25A2  (18). 


5 


Collectively  these  experiments  will  indicate  the  relative  importance  of  each  Cy  mo^s  (both 
on  the  inhibitor  and  on  the  substrate)  for  kinase  inhibition.  In  addition  these  experiments 
will  reveal  whether  there  is  specificity  encoded  in  the  Cy  motifs  (Cyl  or  Cy2)  with  regard 
to  which  cyclin  (A  or  E)  is  preferentially  targeted. 

Fig.  2B  shows  that  PSKX),  the  12  amino  acid  peptide  containing  the  Cy  motif 
(ACEELEGPVDSE),  inhibits  the  activity  of  cyclin  E-cdk2  with  an  IC50  of  about  200 

ng/25  jxL  (6  |xM).  In  contrast  the  mutant  peptide,  PS  101  (ACRRLKKPVDSE)  is  inactive 

up  to  10000  ng  (300  ^M).  In  comparison  an  IC50  of  200  nM  for  PSIOO  was  reported 
when  cyclin  E/cdk2  was  used  to  phosphorylate  GST-RbC  (the  C  terminal  portion  of  the 
retinoblastoma  protein)  (5).  The  12  fold  decrease  in  potency  of  PSIOO  on  CDC25A  could 
be  accounted  by  the  Cy  motif  on  CDC25  A  (the  substrate  used  here)  having  a  higher  affinity 
for  cyclin  E/cdk2  than  the  Cy  motif  on  Rb.  This  question  will  be  addressed  by  using 
peptides  that  encode  Cy  motifs  from  other  substrates  of  cdks  (Rb,  CDC25A  and 
CDC6/Cdcl8). 

Mutagenesis  of  the  Cy  motif  of  p21. 

Of  the  three  methods  considered,  we  had  initially  focused  on  a  PCR  based  strategy 
to  change  the  first  R  (R1  to  A)  and  the  second  R  (R2  to  A)  of  the  Cy  motif  of  GST-p21N. 
However,  we  failed  to  obtain  the  correct  mutant  by  this  method. 

We  then  tried  the  cassette  based  mutagenesis  strategy.  This  is  the  method  that  we 
hope  to  optimize  because  if  successful,  cassettes  with  degenerate  oUgonucleotides  will 
provide  an  easy  way  to  produce  a  library  of  mutants  in  die  Cy  motif  of  GST-p21N.  Two 
types  of  ligations  have  been  tried  using  the  R1  to  A  and  R2  to  A  mutagenic  oligos  for 
optimization.  Unphosphorylated  oligos  have  been  ligated  to  un-phosphatased  GEX-p21N 
plasmid  cut  open  with  Hindlll  and  Blpl.  For  comparison,  kinases  oligo-cassette  has  been 
ligated  to  GEXp21N  plasmid  linearized  by  HindHI  and  Blpl  and  de-phosphorylated  with 
shrimp  alkaline  phosphatase.  Using  the  first  ligation  approach  we  obtained  mutants  at  an 
unusually  low  frequency  (2  out  of  1 8),  which  is  sub-optimal  for  making  a  library  of 
mutants.  Currently  we  are  awaiting  the  results  from  the  second  ligation  approach. 

Determination  of  the  part  of  PCNA  that  interacts  with  p21  and  Fenl. 

In  vitro  transcribed  -translated  PCNA  (wild  type  and  mutants)  were  bound  to 
glutathione  agarose  beads  coated  with  GST-p21 ,  GST-FenlC  and  (3ST  (negative 
control).  No  difference  was  seen  in  the  binding  of  the  mutants  to  p21  or  Fenl  (not 
shown),  a  result  that  contradicts  with  the  published  report  (17).  We  reasoned  that  non¬ 
radioactive  wild-type  PCNA  subunits  in  the  rabbit  reticulocyte  lysate  may  form  heteromers 
with  the  radiolabeled  mutants  and  facilitate  their  association  with  p21  or  Fenl  giving  a  false 
positive  result.  Wild  type  and  mutant  PCNA  were  therefore  synthesized  in  E.  coli  (which 
do  not  contain  wild  type  eukaryotic  PCNA),  lysates  containing  the  PCNA  prepared,  and 
the  binding  of  PCNA  to  GST,  GST-p21  and  GST-FenlC  assayed.  Fig.  3  shows  that  wild 
type  PCNA  and  several  of  the  mutants  successfully  bound  to  p21  and  to  Fenl.  However, 
in  agreement  with  published  results,  a  mutation  that  changed  the  QLGI  in  the  inter-domain 
loop  of  PCNA  to  AAAA,  resulted  in  PCNA  that  failed  to  bind  to  p21  and  Fenl. 

Therefore  we  have  at  least  one  derivative  of  PCNA  that  has  lost  interaction  with 
Fenl  and  p21.  PCNA  with  QLGI  changed  to  AAAA  has  been  purified  to  homogeneity 
over  nickel-resin  and  Mono-Q  columns  (Fig.  4)  preparatory  to  analyzing  its  effect  on 
polymerase  delta  and  its  effect  on  genomic  stability  of  direct  repeats  in  an  in  vitro  DNA 
replication  reaction.  In  addition,  finer  mutations  will  now  be  made  in  and  around  the  QLGI 


6 


region  of  PCNA  to  produce  mutant  forms  of  PCNA  that  selectively  lose  interaction  with 
p21,  Fenl  or  polymerase  delta.  If  such  mutant  forms  of  PCNA  ^e  found,  over-expression 
of  such  proteins  during  in  vitro  or  in  vivo  replication  reactions  will  address  the  relative 
roles  of  these  interactions  in  (a)  maintenance  of  genomic  stability  and  (b)  the  effect  of  p21 
on  DNA  replication  and  genomic  stability. 

CONCLUSIONS 

The  cyclin-binding  motif  of  p21  appears  to  be  much  more  important  than  the  cdk 
binding  K  motif  for  inhibiting  the  phosphorylation  of  substrates  like  CDC25A  that  contain 
exactly  similar  cyclin-binding  Cy  motifs.  Future  experiments  will  establish  whether  Ais  is 
true  by  quantitative  comparisons  between  substrates  with  different  Cy  motifs  and  inhibitors 
(p21  or  synthetic  peptides)  with  different  Cy  sequences.  Preliminary  experiments  are  still 
in  progress  to  help  select  the  optimal  method  of  mutagenesis  to  make  a  library  of  mutant  Cy 
motif  in  p21.  The  best  method  we  have  till  now  is  successful  at  the  rate  of  2  out  of  18 
clones.  If  further  improvement  is  not  obtained  by  the  other  methods,  we  shall  use  this 
method  to  generate  the  mutants  and  test  them.  Mutant  forms  of  PCNA  have  been  generated 
that  fail  to  interact  with  both  p21  and  Fenl.  Finer  mutations  in  PCNA  over  this  region  will 
allow  us  to  distinguish  the  relative  importance  of  PCNA-pol  delta,  PCNA-Fenl  and 
PCNA-p21  interactions  for  the  inhibition  of  DNA  replication  and  the  maintenance  of 
genomic  stability 

FIGURE  LEGENDS 

Fig.  1  Rate  of  phosphorylation  of  a  substrate  GST-CDC25A  by  cyclin  E-cdk2  under 
conditions  described  in  the  text.  Y-axis:  cpm  of  32P  incorporated  in  the  GST-CDC25A 
band.  X-axis:  Time  of  kinase  reaction. 

Fig.  2  Inhibition  of  cyclin  E-cdk2.  (A)  Addition  of  indicated  amounts  of  GST-p21 
(squares),  GST-p21  A17-24  (circles;  deletion  of  cyclin  E  binding  motif)  and  GST-p21 

A53-58  (diamonds;  deletion  of  cdk2  binding  motif).  The  amount  of  32P  incorporated  into 
GST-CDC25A  at  10  minutes  (initial  velocity  conditions)  is  expressed  as  percentage  of  32P 
incorporated  in  the  uninhibited  reaction  (100%  kinase  activity).  (B)  Addition  of  synthetic 
peptides  PSIOO  (squares;  wild  type  Cyl  motif)  and  PSIOI  (diamonds;  mutant  Cy  motif). 
The  rest  is  the  same  as  in  part  A. 

Fig.  3  QLGI  PCNA  fails  to  bind  to  Fenl  or  to  p21.  PCNA  bound  to  GST  (GEX), 
GST-FENIC  (GEX-FENIC)  and  GST-p21  (GEX-p21)  was  visualized  by  immunoblotting 
with  anti-PCNA  antibody  (top).  10%  of  the  PCNA  input  into  the  reactions  is  directly 
visualized  by  immunoblotting  (bottom),  wt:  wild-type  PCNA.  VDK:  Vall88,  Aspl89 
and  Lysl90  of  PCNA  changed  to  Ala.  QLGI:  Glnl25,  Leul26,  Glyl27  and  Ilel28  of 
PCNA  changed  to  Ala.  SHV:  Ser43,  His44  and  Val45  of  PCNA  changed  to  Ala.  LAPK: 
Leu251,  Pro253  and  Lys254  of  PCNA  changed  to  Ala. 

Fig.  4  QLGI  125  to  AAAA  form  of  PCNA  purified  to  homogeneity  and  visualized  by 
Coomasie  Blue  staining  after  SDS-polyacrylamide  gel  electrophoresis. 


7 


GEX 

D  I  GEX-FEN1C 
^  I  GEX-P21 


LU 

CD 


lil^ 

>S:  ik 

UJ  UJ 
CD  CD 


O 

T“ 

Z  T- 
UJ  CM 

u.  a 
X  >!:  X 

UJ  UJ  UJ 

CD  CD  CD 


QLGI 


Wt 


SHV 


LAPK 


VDK  QLGI  Wt  SHV  LAPK 


0.1  X  Input 


Fig.  3 


11 


Purification  of  PCNA  Mutant 

QLGi 


Fig.  4 


QLGI 


12 


REFERENCES 

1.  el  Deiry,  W.  S.,  Tokino,  T.,  Velculescu,  V.  E.,  Levy,  D.  B.,  Parsons,  R.,  Trent,  J.  M.,  Lin, 
D.,  Mercer,  W.  E.,  Kinder,  K.  W.,  Vogelstein,  B.  (1993).  WAFl,  a  potential  mediator  of 
p53  tumor  suppression  Cell  75,  817-25 

2.  Waga,  S.,  Hannon,  G.  J.,  Beach,  D.,  Stillman,  B.  (1994).  The  p21  inhibitor  of  cyclin- 
dependent  kinases  controls  DNA  replication  by  interaction  with  PCNA  [see  comments]  Nature 

369,  574-8  ,  .  o  x 

3.  Rores-Rozas,  H.,  Kelman,  Z.,  Dean,  F.  B.,  Pan,  Z.-Q.,  Harper,  J.  W.,  Elledge,  S.  J., 
O'Donnell,  M.,  Hurwitz,  J.  (1994).  Cdk-interacting  protein  1  directly  binds  with  proliferating 
cell  nuclear  antigen  and  inhibits  DNA  replication  catalyzed  by  the  DNA  polymerase  delta 
holoenzyme.  Proc.  Natl.  Acad.  Set  USA  91,  8655-8659 

4.  Chen,  J.,  Jackson,  P.  K.,  Kirschner,  M.  W.,  Dutta,  A.  (1995).  Separate  domains  of  p21 
involved  in  the  inhibition  of  cdk  kinase  and  PCNA.  Nature  374, 386-388 

5.  Chen,  J.,  Saha,  P.,  Kombluth,  S.,  Dynlacht,  B.  D.,  Dutta,  A.  (1996).  Cyclin  binding  motifs 
are  essential  for  the  function  of  p21/CIPl  Mol.  Cell.  Biol.  16, 4673-4682 

6.  Russo,  A.  A.,  Jeffrey,  P.  D.,  Patten,  A.  K.,  Massague,  J.,  Pavletich,  N.  P.  (1996).  Crystal 
structure  of  the  p27(kipl)  cyclin-dependent-kinase  inhibitor  bound  to  the  cyclm  a  cdk2 
complex  Nature  382,  325-331 

7.  Luo,  Y.,  Hurwitz,  J.,  Massague,  J.  (1995).  Cell-cycle  inhibition  by  independent  cdk  and 
PCNA  binding  domains  in  p21-Cipl.  Nature  375, 159-161 

8.  Chen,  J.,  Peters,  R.,  Saha,  P.,  Lee,  P.,  Theodoras,  A.,  Pagano,  M.,  Wagner,  G.,  Dutta,  A. 
(1996).  A  39  amino  acid  domain  of  the  cdk  inhibitor  p21  is  sufficient  to  bind  PCNA  and 
partially  inhibit  DNA  replication  in  vivo.  Nucleic  Acids  Research  24,  1727-1733 

9.  Waga,  S.  and  Stillman,  B.  (1994).  Anatomy  of  a  DNA  replication  fork  revealed  by 
reconstitution  of  SV40  DNA  replication  in  vitro  Nature  369, 207-12 

10.  Harrington,  J.  J.  and  Lieber,  M.  R.  (1994).  Functional  domains  within  FEN-1  and  RAD2 
define  a  family  of  strucmre-specific  endonucleases:  implications  for  nucleotide  excision  repair 
Genes  &  Development  S,  1344-55 

11. Hiraoka,  L.  R.,  Harrington,  J.  J.,  Gerhard,  D.  S.,  Lieber,  M.  R.,  Hsieh,  C.  L.  (1995). 
Sequence  of  human  FEN-1,  a  structure-specific  endonuclease,  and  chromosomal  localization 
of  the  gene  (FENl)  in  mouse  and  human  Genomics  25, 220-5 

12.  Murray,  J.  M.,  Tavassoli,  M.,  al,  H.  R.,  Sheldrick,  K.  S.,  Lehmann,  A.  R.,  Carr,  A.  M., 
Watts,  F.  Z.  (1994).  Structural  and  functional  conservation  of  the  human  homolog  of  the 
Schizosaccharomyces  pombe  rad2  gene,  which  is  required  for  chromosome  segregation  and 
recovery  from  DNA  damage  Molecular  &  Cellular  Biology  14, 4878-88 

13.  Vallen,  E.  A.  and  Cross,  F.  R.  (1995).  Mutations  in  rad27  define  a  potential  link  between  g(l) 
cyclins  and  dna  replication  Molecular  &  Cellular  Biology  15, 4291-4302 

14.  Reagan,  M.  S.,  Pittenger,  C.,  Siede,  W.,  Friedberg,  E.  C.  (1995).  Characterization  of  a 
mutant  strain  of  saccharomyces  cerevisiae  with  a  deletion  of  the  rad27  gene,  a  structural 
homolog  of  the  rad2  nucleotide  excision  repair  gene  Journal  of  Bacteriology  177, 364-37 1 

15.  Johnson,  R.  E.,  Kovvali,  G.  K.,  Prakash,  L.,  Prakash,  S.  (1995).  Requirement  of  the  yeast 
rthl  5'  to  3'  exonuclease  for  the  stability  of  simple  repetitive  dna  Science  269, 238-240 

16.  Chen,  J.,  Chen,  S.,  P.,  S.,  Dutta,  A.  (1996).  p21  disrupts  the  recruitment  of  Fenl  to  the 
DNA  replication  apparatus  by  a  Fenl-PCNA  interaction.  Proc.  Natl.  Acad.  Sci.  USA.  93, 
11597-11602 

17.  Jonsson,  Z.  O.,  Hindges,  R.,  Hubscher,  U.  (1998).  Regulation  of  DNA  replication  and  repair 
proteins  through  interaction  with  the  front  side  of  proliferating  cell  nuclear  antigen  Embo  J 17, 
2412-25 

18.  Saha,  P.,  Eichbaum,  Q.,  Silberman,  E.  D.,  Mayer,  B.  J.,  Dutta,  A.  (1997).  p21  and  Cdc25A: 
competition  between  an  inhibitor  and  an  activator  of  cyclin-dependent  kinases.  Mol.  Cell.  Biol. 
17,  4338-4345 


13